I run an exercise in almost every session I teach that I’ve done over a hundred times. Students turn their phones into a voting poll, I put a real résumé on the screen (personal information blurred out, of course), and they get 10-ish seconds to scan it and vote: would you want to learn more about this candidate?
This week, the first résumé went up on the screen, I counted to ten, and a student’s hands flew up in the air. In front of 50 other students, she told me she thought the activity was stupid. Stupid. It threw me off my game a little bit, I won’t even lie to y’all, but I wanted to know why, so I asked. She said it’s stupid to judge somebody based on 10 seconds.
But I told her: nobody is judging you. They’re judging the materials you put in front of them. And it’s not even really judging. We are evaluating what’s in front of us based on the context you give us. Ten seconds is not the verdict. It’s just the audition for more time. Nobody gets hired or rejected off a 10-second scan.
And I also told her I could understand why she’d think the scan is the judgment, because if nobody has ever explained it, of course it feels that way. But understanding what that scan actually is, is the whole point of the exercise.
Then I asked her to walk me through what she thinks happens when someone submits a résumé for a job.
“I don’t know. Just not like that.”
That answer has been sitting with me, hard, in my gut, for the past day or so. Because after that moment, she was done. No more votes. No more questions. No more engagement for the rest of the session.
The rest of the room leaned in after that, and we had one of the most honest conversations I’ve had all semester. She just wasn’t part of it.
And the part that really gets me is that this was a session for peer mentors. She was sitting in a room with other peer mentors from schools across the state of Washington, and I know that you don’t become a peer mentor by accident. I know she is an incredible student leader with exceptional leadership experience, but all of that leadership experience is not going to be nearly as beneficial for her if she does not understand contextually how to position it to an employer.
A lot of the time, in my work as a career readiness speaker, I’ve noticed that people in the education system want to upskill students, which I think is incredible. But we can only upskill somebody so far without teaching them how to maneuver those skills inside of a process that gets them the actual job.
We spend so much time having students replicate “good” résumés. We do not spend nearly enough time helping them fill in the blanks of their own experience for a reader who knows absolutely nothing about them. Because that’s what helps them get noticed. When somebody (probably a recruiter) is scanning their résumé for 10, 15 seconds, can they find what they’re looking for, easily? Is there enough depth in there for them to actually understand what the student does? And does it look like a final deliverable, something a company would be happy to put in front of a client?
Because I wish more people knew that recruiters aren’t scanning for perfection. We are scanning for context. And context buys the candidate more time.
I think we need to stop asking students to think like perfectionists and start asking them to think like really good explainers. The resume has one job: to explain your experience to a stranger, quickly, with enough context to picture what you actually do, and at the scale that you actually do it. When we teach them that, the “really hard” job market becomes much less hard.
Talk soon? Nicki 😊
career readiness speaker for students, college and career readiness speaker, career speaker for high school, student career readiness keynote speaker, workforce readiness speaker college, career planning workshop high school, career development speaker for students, career readiness keynote speaker, career guidance speaker for college students, student career speaker interactive workshop