Hot Take? Being a Hiring Manager Does Not Make You an Expert on How People Get Jobs

We talk a lot about making students “career ready” but where are they actually getting stuck? Because we can’t choose the right solution until we diagnose the actual problem.

There is a phrase I hear constantly in conversations about students and their next steps:

“We need to make sure they’re prepared.”

Absolutely. But what does prepared actually mean? Because saying students aren’t prepared is a little like saying something isn’t working. It tells us there is a problem, but it doesn’t tell us what the problem is.

A student could be underprepared because they have no idea what they want to do.

Another student could know exactly what they want to do but have no idea where to find internships or jobs for that thing.

Another could be finding the right opportunities and applying to dozens of them, but never getting an interview.

Another student could have a strong resume and consistently get interviews, but struggle to turn those interviews into offers.

All of those students could be described as needing more “career readiness.” But what is “more”, and what exactly do they need more of? 

Because we cannot provide the right solution until we have appropriately diagnosed the problem. And most of us are either skipping this step or assuming it entirely🫠

If students don’t know what they want to do, a resume workshop probably isn’t going to solve that. If they know exactly what they want but have applied to 100 jobs without getting an interview, another career exploration assessment probably isn’t the answer.

But most of us decide we need a workshop, which probably leads us to deciding we should bring in a speaker. 

I think we should reverse it. And yes, I know that is a strong opinion, especially coming from someone who makes a living off of being a career readiness speaker. But hear me out. 

First, I think we should ask our students: where are they actually getting stuck? And what data or proof do we have to support that? 

Then, we should think through what intervention would address that specific problem. 

And finally, who has the right experience and vantage point to deliver it? Now the last question is one I don’t think we ask nearly enough.

I see a good example of this in the career coaching industry (and if you’re still reading, BUCKLE UP, because this IS going to ruffle a lot of feathers). 

There are many career coaches who position themselves as former “hiring managers” at major companies. And hear me loud and clear, there is absolutely value and having hiring manager experience. It’s also important to understand what that term actually means.

“Hiring Manager” typically isn’t someone’s job title .

Someone may be an Engineering Manager, a Marketing Director, a Senior Project Manager or other leader responsible for a team. When that team needs to hire someone, that person serves as the “Hiring Manager” for the search. And that means their experience with the hiring process may come primarily from a very specific part of the funnel. That also means that their expertise relies on the function of the role, not the recruiting ecosystem the role lives inside of. 99.9% of students don’t need expertise in the role, they need to learn the mechanics in how to get the role. 

Think about it like the Olympics. Imagine someone who has spent years judging athletes at the Olympic level. They know exactly what exceptional performance looks like. They know what separates a good competitor from an outstanding one. And when several incredibly talented athletes are competing against one another, they know what can make one person stand out.

That expertise is valuable. But make no mistake, it is value-able in a hyper-specific, highly concentrated situation. 

Now imagine you’re an athlete who can’t make it through the qualifying rounds. Would you automatically assume that the Olympic-level judge is the best person equipped to explain why?

I wouldn’t. Because the Olympic-level judge only sees the athletes who made it to that level. And the hiring process works the same way. 

By the time a candidate reaches a Hiring Manager, that person may have already survived a resume review, multiple eyes on their application, likely a stop-gap assessment, and potentially a phone screen (almost always done by the Recruiter). 

The hiring manager may be comparing five outstanding candidates. What they may have not seen are the other 995 applicants who never reached them.

So their perspective isn’t wrong. It’s specific. 

A hiring manager has incredible insight into what makes one qualified finalist more compelling than another.

A recruiter has very different insight into why someone isn’t becoming a finalist in the first place.

And this is one of my biggest qualms with career-readiness programming…that it often relies on the Hiring Manager or even employee perspective. 

It doesn’t address the system that 99.9% of students struggle with. It does not dispel myths about the hiring process (and myths that in many times, the hiring managers and employees are reinforcing because they don’t actually know any different). 

And that’s why I think we should pivot away from the question “what career programming should we offer our students?” and start asking something much more specific: 

“Where, and with what, exactly, are our students getting stuck?” 

Once we know that, “career readiness” stops being a vague goal. It becomes a problem we can actually solve.

With (tough) love, 

-Nicki 😇

I send an email every Friday with bite-sized content like this to help make career readiness simpler.

Interested in working with Nicki?

To inquire about speaking engagements with Nicki, please call (800) 799-1460 or visit the link below: